At the start of September, a new build at 12846 Highwood Street in Brentwood Park sold for $26 million. The house first came to market in 2023 at $39.9 million, or $3,049 a square foot. Its last ask was $34.5 million. According to The Real Deal, it closed at $1,988 a square foot after nearly three years on the market. The seller was Kurt Rappaport, co-founder of Westside Estate Agency, who represented himself. He described the buyer as a local business executive and told the outlet the sale was "another indication of the acceleration we're just starting to see at the top of the L.A. market."
He may be right about where the market is heading. Highwood is also the clearest example of something that has held for every widely reported trophy sale in Brentwood this year. The original asking price has been a weak guide to the closing price, and the reduced asking price has not been much better. For a buyer comparing Brentwood with Bel Air or Beverly Hills, the number to work from is the closed price per square foot, read against the lot.
Three Public Closings, One Gap
Three Brentwood homes listed in the high-$30 millions or above closed in public deals between February and September 2026. Here is each one's full price history.
| Address | Original ask | Last ask | Closed | Closed per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12833 Chalon Road | $58.5M, July 2025 | $49.5M | $40M, February 2026 | $4,016 |
| 1204 Chickory Lane | $38M, August 2025 | just under $35M | $29M, reported July 2026 | not reported |
| 12846 Highwood Street | $39.9M, 2023 | $34.5M | $26M, September 2026 | $1,988 |
The Chalon Road estate in Brentwood Country Estates belonged to Douglas Emmett's Ken Panzer. The Real Deal reported that it closed in February for $40 million, plus a separate $1 million for furniture. When it first listed in July 2025, it was Brentwood's most expensive home on the market. That works out to about 32% under the first ask and about 19% under the last one. The Chickory Lane house, called The Outlook, is a 0.7-acre hilltop spec home from developer David Maman's firm. It appeared in a Fanatics Sportsbook Super Bowl ad with Kendall Jenner. The Real Deal reported that it sold for $29 million, nearly 24% under its August 2025 ask and about 17% under the cut ask. Highwood closed 35% under its first ask and 25% under its last.
How long each house sat made little difference to the size of the gap. Chalon took about seven months from first listing to close and still finished about 32% under its opening number. Chickory took about eleven months and finished about 24% under. Highwood took nearly three years and finished 35% under. The fastest sale had a larger gap than the eleven-month one, and the three gaps fall in a band about eleven points wide. In each case the buyer paid roughly a quarter to a third less than the first ask.
The Reduced Ask Was Not the Floor
On a Brentwood listing sheet, a price cut usually looks like the seller has reached their real number. This year's closings don't support that. All three homes went under contract below the reduced ask, by between about 17% and 25%. A buyer who took the last ask as the starting point for an offer would have paid well over the eventual clearing price at every one of these addresses.
The Real Deal's own read of the Chickory sale was that it was more evidence of a gap between trophy-home asking prices and what buyers will pay. In a late-August contracts report, the same outlet described Los Angeles high-end buyers as "price sensitive." It wrote that sellers and buyers had come apart after the megadeals of the pandemic years. Its example was a Bel Air listing on Chantilly Road that first asked $35.7 million in 2023 and was asking nearly $20 million that week. That gap shows up in the asking price, and buyers close it at the table.
The Price Per Square Foot Spread
Closed price per square foot is the more useful number, and in Brentwood it varies widely. Chalon Road traded at $4,016 a square foot inside the gated Brentwood Country Estates. Highwood Street, a newer house in Brentwood Park, traded at $1,988. The two closings sit about seven months apart, and the higher one is roughly double the lower. The spread shows that in this tier, the enclave, the land and the setting carry more of the price than the newness of the house.
The one well-reported off-market trade this year falls between those two figures. In March, Rappaport sold a second Brentwood home at 12928 Evanston Street, on more than half an acre, for $29 million in an off-market deal, or $2,560 a square foot, according to The Real Deal. The house had no public asking history, so its closed figure goes straight into the set of comparables alongside the public sales. Read together, the three closed prices per square foot, $1,988, $2,560 and $4,016, give a better guide to Brentwood's top tier this year than any asking price. Our earlier piece on how off-market listings work in Los Angeles covers how these trades come together.
This Fall's Asking Prices Are Already Coming Down
The same pattern is playing out in this fall's listings. Smashbox co-founder Dean Factor and his wife, Shannon, listed their 9-acre estate at 1900 Old Ranch Road in May for $48.5 million. They cut it to $39.5 million in late August. Their agent, Compass's Tracy Tutor, called it a decision to "reposition the property for today's market and create fresh momentum," The Real Deal reported. That is a cut of about 19% within roughly three months of listing.
In mid-September, the 1937 Georgian Colonial at 251 North Bristol Avenue in Brentwood Park came back on the market for just under $23 million, down from about $30 million earlier in the year. The house is known as the exterior of "The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air." Its new listing agent pointed to the nearly one-acre lot, not the famous facade, as the real draw at a time when larger estates are harder to find, according to The Real Deal. That brings the pricing back to the land, as at Chalon Road.
The listing a buyer can watch from the start is 223 North Carmelina Avenue. Mexican architect Ricardo Legorreta designed the "House of Two Towers" in 1990 for Arthur Greenberg, a founding partner of Greenberg Glusker. It sits on an acre with an interior courtyard and fountain, a pool and a tennis court. The Real Deal reported that it came to market in October for the first time, at just under $30 million, or $3,215 a square foot. That asking price is below Chalon Road's closed figure and well above Highwood's and Evanston's. The house has a named architect and has had a single owner since it was built. As we wrote about provenance in Trousdale Estates, authorship can support a price that comparable square footage alone would not. Carmelina will test how much of that holds in Brentwood this year.
Contract Activity Across the County This Fall
Rappaport's comment about acceleration deserves a look at the wider numbers. The Real Deal's weekly counts of Los Angeles County homes asking $4 million or more have mostly run below last year's pace this fall. One September week recorded 22 contracts, down 12% year over year. A week reported October 7 had 13 contracts and $100.7 million in asking volume, down 60% from the same week a year earlier. The following week had 24 contracts against 29 a year before. In the week ended October 18, there were 16 contracts, down 6%, with $101.5 million in asking volume, down 16%, per the outlet's roundup.
Those weekly counts measure asking prices across the whole county, starting at $4 million, so they don't tell us what Brentwood's top tier will close at. They do show that deals are still getting done at a steady pace without demand surging enough to push buyers back toward the first asking price.
Using the Numbers in an Offer
A buyer reading a Brentwood listing this season can rely on three numbers in this order. The first is the closed price per square foot of the nearest comparable trade in the same enclave, including off-market deals. The second is the land, since that is what agents keep pointing to as the scarce part. The third is the asking price, read as what the seller hopes to get. On this year's evidence, both the first and reduced asks have run above the clearing price. Old Ranch Road, Bristol Avenue and Carmelina Avenue are the three addresses that will show whether the pattern carries into 2027. Each started from a different point: a recent cut, a relisting and a first-ever ask.
For anyone weighing the neighborhood more broadly, our Brentwood neighborhood page covers the enclaves, and our comparison of Bel Air and Beverly Hills for privacy-minded buyers applies the same kind of reading to Brentwood's nearest competitors.
If you are weighing an offer on one of this fall's listings, or deciding where to set an ask of your own, Brendan Brown can go through the comparable sales with you privately. Schedule a confidential consultation.